‘It just wasn’t very buttery’: the best (and worst) unsalted butter, tasted and rated | The food filter

6 hours ago 6

Unsalted butter is easily one of my most used ingredients. At any given time, I have at least four blocks in my fridge, ready to be softened and whipped into cakes or rubbed into flour for pastry. There is a camp of people who prefer to use salted butter for baking, and while there are definitely instances where that has its place (think shortbread and cookies), I find it much easier and more consistent to be able to control the salt level myself, especially because it varies so much between brands.

However, I tasted each butter on its own (much harder than you think!) and spread it on a plain cracker. The differences between them were much more subtle than I’d been expecting and, for the most part, it was hard to tell which was which. I don’t think you can go too wrong when deciding what to choose, especially if you’re using the butter in baking. But, personally, I avoid those newly downsized 200g blocks – they can work out to nearly double the price a kilo!

Best all-rounder
Waitrose Essential unsalted butter

_{£2.25 for 250g at Waitrose}★★★★★

A strong contender. The butter flavour comes through pretty well, it’s creamy without being greasy and has a soft, sweet smell. A very good all-rounder, I’d say.

Best bargain
Marks & Spencer unsalted British butter

_{£2 for 250g at Ocado}★★★★★

This immediately stood out from the others. It has the strongest, butter-forward, creamy flavour, and it spreads really well, too. It also happens to be the cheapest of the bunch, so it’s a win-win!

Best splurge
Country Life unsalted butter

_{£2.60 for 250g at Waitrose}
_{£3.10 for 250g at Sainsbury’s}★★★★☆

This has the most notable aroma, with a subtle sweetness to it. It leans towards the creamier side and I’d happily use it in cakes and pastries.

And the rest …

Yeo Valley organic unsalted butter

_{£3.20 for 200g at Waitrose}_{£3.05 for 200g at Sainsbury’s}★★★☆☆

The only organic option here, and one of those smaller 200g blocks, which I don’t love. The butteriness is pretty subtle, but this has a lovely creaminess and good mouthfeel.

Lurpak unsalted butter

_{£2.15 for 200g at Waitrose}_{£2.15 for 200g at Ocado}★★★★☆

One of the best for spreading consistency at room temperature. Faintly sweet, good creaminess and one I’d be inclined to use to make compound butters.

skip past newsletter promotion

Müller unsalted British butter

_{£2.20 for 250g at Co-Op}★★★★☆

A pleasantly clean and milky flavour that doesn’t leave a greasy aftertaste. A solid all-rounder.

Sainsbury’s unsalted British butter

_{£1.99 for 250g at Sainsbury’s}★★★☆☆

Another neutral-leaning option that won’t steer you far wrong. It spreads quite nicely and has a very subtle butter flavour.

Cowbelle British unsalted butter

_{£1.99 for 250g at Aldi}★★★☆☆

A mild and plain-tasting butter, but it doesn’t have the best spreadability at room temperature. A fine option for baking when you need a neutral backdrop.

Tesco unsalted butter

_{£1.99 for 250g at Tesco}★★☆☆☆

The most neutral-tasting of them all, and neither here nor there. Fine for when you’re looking for a blank canvas to add your own flavour, but it just isn’t very buttery.