Starmer calls on Labour to stop ‘navel-gazing’ and join ‘fight of our times’ as Labour conference begins – UK politics live

Key events

Show key events only

Please turn on JavaScript to use this feature

Starmer says Reform's indefinite leave to remain policy immoral and 'racist'

Q: Do you think the Reform UK indefinite leave to remain policy is immoral?

Yes, says Starmer.

He says it is one thing to remove illegal migrants.

But removing people who are settled in the UK is a “completely different thing”, he says.

He says most elections in this country have been between Labour and the Conservatives.

But Reform are different, he says. It is the sort of politics we have seen in France or Germany, he says (implying they are far-right).

Q: Do you think this is a racist policy?

I do think that it is a a racist policy, I do think it is immoral and it needs to be called out for what it is.

But Starmer says he is not saying people who are considering voting for Reform are racist. They are people “frustrate” by the lack of change, he says.

Starmer says Reform UK's plan to scrap indefinite leave to remain for migrants who have it would 'tear country apart'

Q: What is patriotic renewal?

Starmer gives examples of what the government is doing to get the economy going.

And he says Reform UK would tear the country apart.

He highlights Nigel Farage’s plan to rescind indefinite leave to remain from migrants who have already been granted this status.

I want to serve the whole of our country, our beautiful, tolerant, diverse country …

Reform not believe in that country. They want to tear that country apart. What was said last week about deporting migrants who are lawfully here, who’ve been here for years working in our hospitals, in our schools, running businesses, our neighbours and reform say they want to deport them. That would tear our country apart.

(This is a much harder line than the one Labour was using against the Reform policy last week, when it focused on practical flaws in what Farage was proposing.)

He also accuses Reform of “cosying up to Putin”.

Starmer stresses he always said turning Britain around would take time, in response to questions about poor Labour polling

Keir Starmer is being interviewed by Laura Kuenssberg on the BBC now.

Q: How much trouble are you in?

Starmer says the government has done “a lot”, and accomplished “great things”.

He lists a series of achievements.

Q: Poll suggest Labour would win fewer than 100 seats if there were an election now.

Starmer says he always said it will take time.

He will be judged at the next election by whether people feel better off.

Q: Do you accept you are in trouble?

Starmer says he is focusing on delivering. He mentions the Hillsborough law.

Steve Reed says he is confident Starmer will lead Labour into next election, after poll suggests members want him replaced

Steve Reed, the housing secretary, was interviewed by Trevor Phillips on Sky News this morning.

Asked about the Survation poll for LabourList (see 8.59am),, Reed said he was confident that Keir Starmer would lead the party into the next election. He said:

[Starmer has] been written off many, many times over his career.

People said that Keir Starmer could not win a general election for Labour. He picked this party up off the floor and he led us to a landslide victory in the general last year.

53% of Labour members want new leader before election, poll suggests

More than half of Labour party members want a new leader before the general election, a new poll suggests.

The Survation poll, commissioned by the website LabourList, found that 53% of members said the party should get a new leader before the general election, and only 31% said Keir Starmer should stay in place.

Poll of Labour members Photograph: Sky News

The same poll found that 64% of Labour members said they thought Starmer had governed badly since entering office.

Poll of Labour members Photograph: Sky News

And it found that 65% of them think the party is heading in the wrong direction.

Poll of Labour members Photograph: Sky News

Commenting on the poll, which surveyed 1,254 LabourList readers who say they are party members, Emma Burnell, the LabourList editor, said:

The phrase ‘make or break conference speech’ is wildly overused in politics. So much so, that you try to reach for other things to say.

But the plain truth is Starmer has to do an awful lot this week to convince his party he has a plan to turn things around and the capability to achieve a revival of Labour’s fortunes.

Labour members will need to see a plan for change that goes beyond a slogan. But they will also be looking for a passionate messenger who can sell that plan to the country. It’s a tall ask, but one Starmer knows he must deliver on.

Party membership polling can sometimes be unreliable. But these findings are not incompatible with recent anecdotal reporting about party activists and some MPs being very concerned about how the party is doing.

Shabana Mahmood says migrants who want indefinite leave to remain should have to be contributing to communities

Although the Sunday Times got an interview with Keir Starmer, there was more news in the Sun on Sunday’s interview with Shabana Mahmood. Here are the main lines. Mahmood was speaking to the paper’s political editor, Kate Ferguson.

• Mahmood said that she wanted to impose new conditions on migrants who want indefinite leave to remain (ILR) in the UK, requiring them to show that they are making a contribution to communities. She told the paper:

I am looking at how to make sure that settlement in our country - long term settlement, indefinite leave to remain - is linked not just to the job you are doing, the salary you get, the taxes you pay, [but] also the wider contribution you are making to our communities.

She said she was inspired by the example of her parents, who came to Birminghan fom Kashmir in the 1960s and 1970s. She said:

They didn’t just come to work - they settled, they made a contribution to the local community, they were volunteers, they got involved in local politics. They did more than simply work and earn a salary.

Last week Reform UK announced that it wants to abolish the ILR status altogether. Mahmood is not proposing that.

But the government has already said it wants to extend the amount of time migrants normally have to wait until they can apply for ILR, from five years to 10 years. And, in some respects, Mahmood’s proposals in the Sun in Sunday echo the plans announced by Kemi Badenoch earlier this year. Badenoch also said people should have to wait 10 years before they can claim ILR, and she said it should only be given to people who are net contributors to the state, and that people who have claimed benefits should not qualify.

As Patrick Maguire reported in the Times last week, in Labour circles “contribution” is now fashionable as an idea that could be applied to public service reform. Mahmood’s interview reflects this thinking.

• Mahmood said that the European convention on human rights and refugee conventions were being “used in a way that was never intended” and said she would propose reforms before Christmas. The Home Office is working on new guidance to the courts on how they should interprete two of the articles in the convention.

• Mahmood said the policy of putting migrants in hotels had been a “total disaster for the country”.

• She said her “jaw hit the floor” when she learned last week about the Home Office spending £600 on a taxi journey for a migrant with a GP appointment a long way from the hotel where they were staying. She ordered a review after a BBC investigation highlighted this.

• She suggested that some of those who have been putting up St George’s flags or union jack flags around the country have the wrong motives. Asked about flags, she said:

I love the St George’s flag and I love the Union Jack. They are flags that I see myself reflected in.And where our flags are being used as a symbol of unity I’m all for it. I would like to see more of our flags actually on our civic institutions …

I think the thing that we have to be careful about is the motives of some - not all - but some of the people that are putting up the flags. They are speaking to nationalism. And I’m a patriot, not a nationalist.

In my vision of patriotism, you can be English in this country and have 1,000 years of history here, or you can be English and look like me. And no one, not Tommy Robinson or anybody else can take my English identity away from me.

Mahmood was referring to concerns that some of those who have been putting up flags are anti-migrant, or racist.

Other ministers asked about flags have declined to accept there is anything negative about the flag-flying trend.

• Mahmood said that Margaret Thatcher was one of her political heroes. In a quickfire question round, asked to name her heroes, Mahmood said:

I have two women who I look up to for their strength and their steel, and that’s Benazir Bhutto and Margaret Thatcher.

Mahmood probably won’t be using this line in her speech to the conference.

Starmer calls on Labour to stop ‘navel-gazing’ and join ‘fight of our times’ as Labour conference begins

Good morning. The Labour party’s four-day annual conference starts this morning in Liverpool and the headline on the Sunday Times splash sums up the challenge facing Keir Starmer: can he pull things round?

Sunday Times splash Photograph: Sunday Times

In party politics terms, what that means is: can Labour recover its lead in the polls? At least, can it do that in time for the next general election? And, in practice that means, can Labour see of the threat from Reform UK. “I think we can pull this round,” Starmer told the Sunday Times, in an interview with its political editor, Caroline Wheeler.

The next four days won’t settle this question. Sometimes political parties get a modest boost in the polls after their party conference, but Labour are about 10 points behind Reform in polls at the moment and no one is expecting them to close that gap this week. But Labour members will be looking for evidence that that party is on the right track. In particular, there are three problems Starmer needs to address. First, he is accused of being a lousy communicator. Will we see any evidence that he is raising his game? Second, he is accused of being not even sure what he wants to communicate in the first place. Commentators, and even some Labour MPs, say they are not clear about the government’s guiding mission. Will we get clarity on that? And, third, voters want clear evidence that Labour is bringing about meaningful change. Will we get policy that ticks that box?

Over the last few weeks some Labour MPs have been talking privately about the benefits of getting a new leader. In his Sunday Times interview, Starmer said the party had to abandon this sort of “navel-gazing”. He said:

It is the fight of our times and we’ve all got to be in it together. We don’t have time for introspection, we don’t have time for navel-gazing. You’ll always get a bit of that at a Labour party conference, but that is not going to solve the problems that face this country.

Once you appreciate the change — in the sense of the division that Reform would bring to our country and the shattering of what we are as a patriotic country — then you realise this is a fight which in the end is bigger than the Labour party.

Here is the agenda for the day.

8.30am: Steve Reed, the housing secretary, and Sharon Graham, the Unite general secretary, are interviewed on Sky’s Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips.

9am: Keir Starmer is interviewed on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg. Other guests include Alan Johnson, a former Labour home secretary, Gary Smith, general secretary of the GMB union, and Labour MP Bell Ribeiro-Addy.

11am: The conference opens.

11.40am: Hollie Ridley, Labour’s general secretary, speaks. In a session on party business, Ellie Reeves, the national policy forum chair, Anna Turley, the Labour chair, and Bev Craig, leader of Manchester city council and leader of the Labour group on the LGA (Local Government Association) also speak.

12.35pm: Steve Reed, the housing secretary, speaks.

2.05pm: Anthony Albanese, the Australian PM and leader of the Australian Labor party, speaks.

2.30pm: Douglas Alexander, the Scottish secretary, speaks.

2.30pm: Peter Kyle, the business secretary, takes part in a Social Market Foundation Q&A at a fringe meeting.

2.45pm: Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, speaks to the conference.

3pm: Jo Stevens, the Welsh secretary, speaks.

3.15pm: Eluned Morgan, the Welsh first minister, speaks.

4pm: Emma Reynolds, the environment secretary speaks at a fringe meeting.

4.30pm: David Lammy, the deputy PM, takes part in a Financial Times Q&A at a fringe meeting.

5pm: Ed Miliband, the energy secretary, takes part in an LCEF (Labour Climate and Environment Forum) Q&A at a fringe meeting.

If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (normally between 10am and 3pm BST at the moment), or message me on social media. I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word.

If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn.bsky.social. The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary.

I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.