University of Glasgow rector cleared of misconduct by medical watchdog over alleged antisemitism

The rector of the University of Glasgow has been cleared of misconduct by a medical watchdog over alleged antisemitism and support for Hamas.

Dr Ghassan Abu-Sitta, a plastic surgeon and prominent Palestinian activist, appeared via video link on Friday before a fitness to practise panel of the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service in Manchester, where a case of misconduct against him was rejected.

It had been brought by the General Medical Council (GMC), which regulates doctors, and was dismissed by the three-person panel after a three-day hearing.

The case related to a newspaper article written by Abu-Sitta for a Lebanese newspaper and two posts on X.

In the article, he had written about the “martyrdom” of Ahmad Nasr Jarrar, who was believed to be a member of Hamas, saying: “The people have no weapon left but revolutionary violence.”

Ian Comfort, the chair of the panel, said the tribunal did not “cherrypick” quotes but considered the article in its entirety, which expressed views critical of political elites in Palestine. Comfort said they could not identify anything that was antisemitic or supportive of terrorism or violence.

Abu-Sitta, who studied at the University of Glasgow and lives in London with his wife and three sons, had also reposted a tweet that said: “We congratulate our brothers in Hamas and our comrades in the Popular Front on the anniversary of their inception.”

Hamas’s political wing became proscribed under the Terrorism Act in 2021. The tribunal said it did not have evidence as to when the tweets were posted other than that it was some time before 2023.

The tribunal further found that the “ordinary reader” would see the tweet as a celebration of an anniversary and not to be “material or moral aid” to terrorism.

A second tweet by the medic spoke of “Martyrs in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine”, referring to a man who carried out the first operation using a suicide belt, in 1974, and a second man, Shams al-Din al-Qazimi, who died during fighting in 1973.

Abu-Sitta said those with an understanding of the political context of the 1970s would see this post as only demonstrating “solidarity” with the Palestinian cause.

Comfort said the tweet, read through the lens of an ordinary, reasonable Arabic reader, could not be seen as inciting or supporting violence or terrorism.

The Kuwaiti-born medic said he had been racially profiled as “inherently violent” because he was a Palestinian and Arab, and accused the organisation UK Lawyers for Israel, which brought the matter to the attention of the GMC, of “trying to destroy my life”.

A spokesperson for UK Lawyers for Israel said: “It is shocking that the tribunal has found it acceptable for doctors to commemorate acts of violence and pay tribute to terrorists. He has brought the profession into disrepute and Jewish patients are likely to be terrified of being treated by him.”

Ros Emsley-Smith, representing the GMC, said Abu-Sitta had “overstepped the boundary of legitimate political speech and into the realms of misconduct”.

The rector of Glasgow University is elected by students. Abu-Sitta is not a member of university staff and does not speak for the university.